kill the apostasy!!!(BY Marmar ELSHEIKH)
Many would say that Islam say to kill Apostates and that is God’s law! That view is widely believed between ordinary Muslims every where without themselves back to Quran and Sunnah and check it by themselves!
I disagree! I am sorry for disagreeing but many things in this regard due to which I personally disagree for this punishment. I give you arguments. If anyone of you is interested in this regard, I can give detail of this point.
1) There are no less than 20 verses in the Quraan, which describe the different cases of apostasy. Not a single verse gives the punishment of apostasy. Allah only gives apostate a warning that he shall be punished severely on the Day of Judgment.
2) The punishment of apostasy is never generally practiced by Prophet Mohamed or his companions. Yes, there are some hadith according to which apostates were killed. But there are some other hadith according to which apostates were made slaves. There are some other hadith according to which apostates were imprisoned and still there are other hadith according to which apostates were exiled or they themselves chose to leave the Islamic area. And most importantly there are hadith according to which apostates were forgiven! Each case depends upon the severity of apostasy.
Secondly, we cannot justify this punishment logically. For example:
a) If we apply this punishment what will be the difference between us and those crusades who applied this punishment in Spain.
b) If we apply this punishment in our countries and non-Muslims apply this punishment in their countries, what logic will we use against them because for every person, his religion is the right religion? In addition, Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world. Will this punishment give benefit to us or loss to us?
c) Is a munafiq more dangerous to us or is an open kafir more dangerous to us? Will this punishment not promote the number of munafiqeen among us?
In conclusion, when I see all these things and then I read following hadith of our beloved prophet.
"Making mistake in forgiving is better that making mistake in punishing"
I cannot help saying," Apostasy is a sin but not a crime. Its punishment should not be killing"
posted by hassouna @ 5:19 PM
5 comments
5 Comments:
Jews, Christians and Muslims all worship the ONE God. Somebody made up the ruling that Muslims should kill apostates, who are not apostates if they are Jews or Christians. What an evil man! There is no compulsion in religion. Who is misinterpreting the Quran????!
Whilst I apprecaite that apostacy is a serious sin to many, certainly to kill someone over it begs the question of how are they supposed to have a chance to repent of their sin, if they are dead ??? Certainly in democratic countries, it cannot be enforced - as like you say there are the rules of freedom of speech - but to be honest in this day and age I cannot see how any country can allow the death sentance for this 'crime'.
I suppose it depends on just what their actions are along with their speech - and just how far they go with their speech for that matter - as to whether it should be punishable - but certainly the death penalty is too severe.
"There are no less than 20 verses in the Quraan, which describe the different cases of apostasy. Not a single verse gives the punishment of apostasy. Allah only gives apostate a warning that he shall be punished severely on the Day of Judgment."
--------------
Enough said. People of other faithes tend to believe everything thing they hear, quiet an irony.
Nice blog. Please accomplish more my Sudani brother.
You have to get out from the bottle to see it first, a fish livin all it's life in ocean won't know what's the ocean till it's pulled out from the water (Finiding Nemo is a great example talkin bout all human beings journey towards apprecaition to what they already have!).
Everyone should be responsible to choose his own religion, we have to leave the labels given to us by our parents and their surroundings when we were born (being Muslim, Jewish, Christian, etc.), we have to take this journey towards God,from the ocean to the beach, and back again, it's our responsibilty as human beings, it's the major purpose of the life given to you..
We will have every Hizbollah women fucked by dogs.
We will send Phallus of ours into ass of All priests moslems.
We will have Khamenei and Rafsanjani and Ahmadinejad and Khatami and Akbar Ganji fucked by a great penis Of donkey and whale .
We will fuck all foreign government which help mullah.
کیر سگ تو کس ننه سید اولاد پیغمبر و کس ننه خود پیامبر اسلام.
کیر خوک تو کس ننه امام حسین.
کیر خر تو کس ننه شیعیان.
صلوات: الله و کیر خر تو کس ننه محمد و آل محمد.
This is a beautiful cultural message for you.
Post a Comment
<< Home